(Note: This review first appeared on Australian Tabletop Gaming Network. Thanks to Wizards of the Coast for the review copy.)
Candlekeep Mysteries is an anthology collection of seventeen short adventures from various authors covering a wide spread of levels. In addition, the book also presents the Forgotten Realms’ largest library, which acts as a framing device for the adventures, and includes a large full-colour map of the library-fortress. I’ll confess that I can’t recommend it to dedicated players. Unlike some of the other supplements, Candlekeep Mysteries doesn’t offer any new races, class options, spells, or other toys to play with. It’s firmly a DM resource, but it’s a very good DM resource.
And quite frankly I’m relieved that the book is dedicated to a certain target audience of DM’s only. I think it’s quite a disservice to the consumer to buy a book where a good portion of it is off-limits or superfluous (Tasha’s Cauldron is a good example as so little of it is useful to those who just play.) So keeping that all in mind, I’ll take a leaf out of Candlekeep’s book and note that likewise this review is full of spoilers and probably not for players either.
Each adventure is somehow based
around a book of some kind and I’ll confess that they are a mixed bag. As a
collection it gets a solid pass (at least a B+) but most importantly it offers
a prospective DM a showcase of the variety of adventure styles available when
running a game. Some are railroaded, others are more open. Some are dungeon
crawls, some are social endeavours. Some are witty and creative, others are
more traditional.
There’s a few interesting particulars
worthy of note. The fact that each adventure goes into detail on it’s book of
choice is great consistency, as is the illustration of said book, but the same
can’t be said of some of the other elements. A big niggle for me is that the
maps for the adventures don’t have a common style guide. I can get over the
cosmetic issues, but some use ten foot squares and others use five foot
squares, and that’s exactly the kind of thing an editor should have been on
like a hawk.
Also, most of the adventures mention
important details presented in the books which the players will discover, but
very few actually offer a handout or other artistic method of presenting this
detail. It all becomes very “tell, not show” and it is a sad oversight especially
noticeable when an adventure actually does stand out by going to this kind of
effort.
But enough chit-chat. Let’s bid the
players adieu and give it a blow-by-blow.
By the by, I’ll confess that I’m not that big on the alternative cover. The font doesn’t quite seem fitting. It seems more at place in some kind of game set around 1900 with mediums, carnivals, and magicians or something.
SPOILERS FORTHWITH
Intro: Candlekeep
The immense library of Candlekeep is
undoubtedly a cool location to base adventures out of, so it’s such a shame
that so few of the adventures take full advantage of it. Most of them simply
use it to throw you a hook in a book and then get you out of there asap. The
map that comes with the book is pretty funky though the reverse could have been
utilised in some way as well (maybe some maps of the bigger floorplans used in
the modules, or something showing where the various adventures are in relation
to the greater geographic area.)
The chapter is bare-boned and
functional with two notable inclusions. The first is the spectral dragon
Miirym, which sadly doesn’t feature in any of the adventures. But I’m most
intrigued by the stat-lines for Candlekeep’s master sages who can each cast
three fireballs per day. That’s a nifty trick, but considering that “any spell
that creates fire is wasted if it is cast within the keep” one wonders why the
hell they have that ability… unless the anti-fire enchantment was created because
all these master sages kept letting loose fireballs all the time…
The Joy of Extradimensional Spaces (Lvl 1)
The premise here is an
extradimensional mansion, which is a fantastic reward to give to a party and I
simply adore the idea. Essentially, the party get into the mansion easily
enough, but then have to work out the secret keyword to get back out.
Sadly, as an adventure it all feels a
bit forced. Any cautious party worth their salt won’t fall for the obvious trap
of sending everyone inside as written, so most DMs will have to engineer some
cleverer way to get them into the mansion. But it’s the justification as to why
this keyword puzzle exists in the first place that really bugs me. Apparently
the previous owner was really worried that someone would get trapped inside so
they scattered a series of books throughout the mansion with letters printed on
the side which can be arranged to spell the word in question. Why they didn’t
just put up a big frikken sign is anyone’s guess. (A good idea would have been
to include some kind of entity trapped inside that can’t work out the puzzle,
which not only explains the lack of sign but also would give the mansion an
antagonist that the module sorely lacks.)
Mazfroth’s Mighty Digressions (Lvl 2)
The hook at the heart of this
adventure is really cute, as it centres around a scam. A group of jackalweres
are using some mimic-like critters to take the form of valuable books which
they can then sell, the profits going toward a resurrection spell for their late
lamia leader.
This is one of those “morality test”
scenarios, it seems, and is an example of where the D&D team is heading in
terms of removing fixed alignment. Sure, the party can simply hack and slash
their way to victory, but they could conceivably also talk their way through
the scenario and get the whole thing done in under forty minutes with everyone
holding hands and kumbaya-ing their way to a peaceful resolution (because we
all know how peaceful and understanding most adventurers are.)
Book of the Raven (Lvl 3)
For those of you looking to get your
players into Ravenloft (or the Shadowfell in general) Book of the Raven offers
a shadow crossing to play around with the dark and gloomy. It offers a lot of
fun toys, such as a good map of a chalet, a very interesting dark magic item,
and a really cute handout to give to the players.
The inhabitants of the chalet are a
fun device, being more interested in scaring off the party rather than actually
hurting them, though there’s also the possibility of sending your party through
the shadow crossing for a showdown with some undead. It’s a bit of a shame that
this gratuitous fight doesn’t have more of an influence over the module, but at
least it does offer a fight.
A Deep and Creeping Darkness (Lvl 4)
Actual villainous antagonists have
been pretty lacking so far in this anthology. The level 1 adventure didn’t have
one at all opting for a puzzle instead, the level 2 went for a fake-out, and
the level 3 also did the fake-out with an obligatory but meaningless fight
option. So it’s nice to have an adventure with a traditional bad guy that can
be bashed up.
A Deep and Creeping Darkness is a pretty by-the-numbers three-hour
convention module which ticks all the boxes without offering anything new or
exciting. Everything about this adventure seems like a shake-and-bake packet
mix of a module; it’s competent, capable, and entertaining enough, but it’s
eventually forgettable. The earlier modules might have been flawed but at least
they tried to do something different; Creeping
Darkness plays it safe and eventually
enters the land of one-session mediocrity.
Shemshime’s Bedtime Rhyme (Lvl 4)
The second level four adventure is
one of the best in the book. A cursed nursery rhyme manages to escape the
confines of its storybook, forcing the PCs and some interesting NPCs to
quarantine themselves within a section of Candlekeep until they can conquer the
dark spirit threatening them all.
So much about this module shows why
it stands out. For one thing it uses the Candlekeep setting to maximum effect.
It offers a proper antagonist and the supporting cast of characters are varied
and intriguing without being overwhelming. It also has a player handout, which
is very welcome.
I’ll confess that more tools could
have been offered to help DMs stress the power and influence of the catchy
mnemonic tune, but despite that minor quibble I stand by Shemshime being one of
the better, more creative, and well-designed offerings in Candlekeep Mysteries. Nice one!
The Price of Beauty (Lvl 5)
Another big fake-out, this adventure
posits a situation that most players will believe too good to be true… which of
course it is. A temple of baths and hot springs belies a sinister secret, which
is all well and good, but few characters are going to be at ease and will
immediately start trying to uncover what’s going on behind the scenes.
Which is great! That’s exactly what
they should do. And I think it’s a credit to the designers that not only will
that good ol’ adventurer suspicion be rewarded but it may also turn against
them. It’s entirely possible that the poor victim at the heart of this prison
will be killed in an overzealous purge by the players. There’s more subtlety to
the design here than expected and the cruelty of its villains is more devious than
anticipated. I like it.
Book of Cylinders (Lvl 6)
This adventure has been getting a bit
of publicity recently due to the designer disowning it. Politics aside, it
seems nobody is really happy with it, and neither am I.
It largely involves some grippli frog
people caught up in a yuan-ti civil war (I’ve never been really keen to have
benevolent snake people in my campaigns, but they’re here if that’s your
thing.) At the end of the day, this isn’t a mess but it’s clunky and I’m not
surprised it was “ruined by committee.” However, what I’ve heard of the
original plan (some kind of setting-shaking major event involving a snake god
intended to make a dent on Forgotten Realms lore) seems more than a little like
an ego trip on behalf of the designer. Feel free to find out more about it
elsewhere.
Mind you, the “book” idea of it being
cylinders you read by rolling them in mud is fantastic.
Sarah of Yellowcrest Manor (Lvl 7)
Y’know, this is another module
(like Creeping Darkness) that is reminiscent of dozens of others I’ve
played. A clue to a murderous crime leads to the investigation of a noble’s
criminal activities, which leads further to uncovering a blasphemous and wicked
cult ripe for some justified homicide and corpse-robbing.
But despite the fact that it’s
nothing new, I still kinda like it, and I think a big part of it has to do with
the fact that the NPCs encountered are really likeable and sympathetic. The
spirit of poor Sarah elicits a desire to do right by her, Sir Vecken is
likeably heroic, and Young Fargo offers a chance of a redemption arc without
sacrificing the opportunity to beat up the villain. The NPCs elevate this
higher in my opinion than it should be.
Lore of Lurue (Lvl 8)
Here’s one for the fairies and
rainbows crowd, which is nice to see. The PCs are thrust into a demiplane
following all the classic fairytale tropes, including a magical forest, a
wicked witch, interactions with pixies, satyrs, and a treant, a dark moonlit
ritual complete with werewolves, and a unicorn who must be cleansed of
corruption. So if you’re the kind of person who thrives on pixie dust you’re in
for a treat here.
Unfortunately, the scenario is
strongly railroaded, which is somewhat alleviated by the fact that it’s all
meant to be following the tale set down in the pages of the book you’ve been
thrown into, so it’s thematically appropriate. But at the end of the day this
module will be subject to taste, and that taste is likely to have a preference
for sugar.
Kandlekeep Dekonstruktion (Lvl 9)
Straight up, this is without doubt
the best adventure in the book.
Writer Amy Vorpahl shows a great deal
of creativity and humour in an adventure that sees an attempt to turn one of
Candlekeep’s towers into a rocket that will blast off into orbit within a
matter of hours. It’s a novel idea which carries through on its premise with a
clever dungeon, some funky new constructs, and a wonderful antagonist (a gnome
tinkerer with the wonderful name Stonky Noptopper. So good!)
If you’re not into comedic games or
just hate fun you might want to give this one a pass, but you’d be doing
yourself a disservice. Kandlekeep
Dekonstruktion is well-written, highly
entertaining, and very clever. It also reminds us that the adventures set in
Candlekeep are some of the best.
Zikran’s Zephyrean Tome (Lvl 10)
There are certain iconic aspects
to Dungeons & Dragons that very rarely come up in actual play. The
titular dragons themselves are surprisingly absent in most games, as is the
opportunity to obtain a wish. So it’s really lovely that we finally get both in
this cracking little adventure, along with a cloud giant stronghold haunted by
the ghosts of its deceased inhabitants, all in the cause of freeing a trapped
djinn.
There’s a lot to like in this module,
which could be easily extended with some more encounters on the trek between
locations, but the stand-out for me is the bronze dragon encounter. It’s
personable enough to engage in some fun roleplaying but also fickle enough to
start a fight if the party are belligerent. As for the rest, it’s only just
behind in quality. A really good bit of fun.
The Curious Tale of Wisteria Vale (Lvl 11)
The setup here is pretty simple. A
heroic bard has been slowly corrupted and his allies have placed him into an
idyllic demiplane prison until they can work out a way to save him. Now they’ve
discovered a cure and it’s the party’s job to go in and administer some
salvation. All pretty straightforward.
But the twist is that there’s a
beholder-sized spanner gumming up the works of this operation, and it’s one of
the better beholders I’ve come across. The fact that it believes the PCs are
harmless figments of its own imagination is not only a fun idea but allows for
a load of entertaining roleplaying possibilities.
The Book of Inner Alchemy (Lvl 12)
It’s great that we’re seeing more
variety in D&D than the tired old Western Tolkien-esque fantasy tropes.
This adventure takes its cues from wuxia martial arts cinema with a temple of
monks seeking immortality through dark arts.
But there’s very little depth
to Inner Alchemy. It’s basically just a big fight scene with a
paper-thin plot and some incredibly B-grade dialogue (Steel Crane’s lines in
particular are hilariously bad). If you’re just looking for a fight (maybe with
a side plate stuffed with ham and cheese) this is fine, but it’s hardly
sophisticated.
The Canopic Being (Lvl 13)
Mummy Lords don’t get as much love as
they should in my opinion; liches often overshadow them in many published
adventures. But I like a good mummy tomb, and The Canopic Being is a solid
example of one. It seems to fill the spot of a Tomb of Horrors-lite module,
with a few devious ideas but none of the blatant unfairness.
My only real issue with it is the
fact that it’s one more module that relies on convenient teleportation portals
to move the party to the action, and too many of the modules in this book are
going with that clumsy tool. But on the plus side, it does have an actual
handout to give to the players, which so many more of the adventures should
have also had.
The Scrivener’s Mark (Lvl 14)
I had to reread this one a few times
to get my head around it. The players are caught up in intrigue between two
major players from the feywild and will have to delve into a subterranean
library to do battle with a villainous archfey. The hook that draws them in is
blackmail; a magical curse starts covering the PCs with writing bestowing both
funky benefits and horrible drawbacks. They will need to destroy their
tormentor before the curse turns them to glass.
Unfortunately what interesting
aspects the module has is offset by some clumsier elements. The use of
telepathy could have been replaced with a less forced method of communication.
The battle with the golems and mummies uses an ugly mechanism of dropping a
quest item whenever a certain number of them are destroyed whereupon more just
spawn in (it feels very much like video game design rather than tabletop
roleplaying, and it bites.) Certainly a better explanation of the fae factions
at play here would have been convenient. Fun villain, though.
Alkazaar’s Appendix (Lvl 15)
If Kandlekeep Dekonstruktion is the best adventure in the book, this is
second best. The background is interesting and well-presented. The NPCs that
accompany the party are likeable and the golem that is so integral to the plot
is ripe for fun roleplaying opportunities. A side quest involving a dragon
tortoise and its chwinga friends is a fantastic optional encounter and I wish
more of the adventures had similarly interesting inclusions.
As for the adventure itself, the
purple worm-infested Hall of Rainbows introduces the backstory through use of
murals which keeps to the theme that Candlekeep Mysteries is meant to be
promoting. The dracolich at the tomb can prove to be a worthy recurring foe,
and the final matter of the sarcophagus offers a set of options that could
potentially drive a wedge between the party. The Appendix is an excellent
adventure, and also has a great voice to the writing (well done, Adam Lee.)
Xanthoria (Lvl 16)
The obligatory lich at the end of the
book is a really fresh take; a druid whose research into the undead caused her
to become a moss-covered horror of lichen and fungus. Furthermore, her
necromancy has created a plague that can only be eradicated by killing the
lich, which itself may test the moral fortitude of the PCs seeing as her
phylactery is a sweet and innocent fairy fella…
This is fairly traditional dungeon delving fare, but there’s enough cute twists to make it stand out. The room with the purple worm is a stand out, but I also especially like the fact that one room has been included specifically with the intention that the party would be able to comfortably rest there. That’s a quality touch.
